Peace in the Middle East

Israeli PM Olmert: Divide Jerusalem, Return Golan, I Was Wrong

by Charles Lenchner

Published October 07, 2008 @ 01:59PM PST

Former Israeli Prime Minister Ehud Olmert gave a holiday interview to Israel's largest daily newspaper, Yediot Ahronot on September 28th. In it, he dropped a few bombshells - divide Jerusalem, return the Golan Heights to Syria, withdraw from all or nearly all of the West Bank. Wow. Uri Avnery translated some of the juiciest bits in his weekly column:

  • "We must reach an agreement with the Palestinians, the essence of which is that we shall actually withdraw from almost all the territories, if not from all the territories. We shall keep in our hands a percentage of these territories, but we shall be compelled to give the Palestinians a similar percentage, because without that there will be no peace."
  • "… including Jerusalem. With special solutions, that I can visualize, for the Temple Mount and the historical holy places … Anyone who wants to keep all the territory of the city will have to put 270 thousand Arabs behind fences within sovereign Israel. That won't work."
  • "I was the first who wanted to impose Israeli sovereignty on all the city. I admit … I was not ready to look into all the depths of reality."
  • "Concerning Syria, what we need first of all is a decision. I wonder if there is one single serious person in Israel who believes it is possible to make peace with Syria without giving up the Golan Heights in the end."
  • "The aim is to try and fix for the first time a precise border between us and the Palestinians, a border that all the world [will recognize]."
  • "Let's assume that in the next year or two a regional war will break out and we shall have a military confrontation with Syria. I have no doubt that we shall smite them hip and thigh [an allusion to Judges 15:8] … [But] what will happen when we win? … Why go to war with the Syrians in order to achieve what we can get anyway without paying such a high price?"
  • "What was the greatness of Menachem Begin? [He] sent Dayan to meet with Tohami [Sadat's emissary] in Morocco, before he even met Sadat … and Dayan told Tohami, on behalf of Begin, that we were prepared to withdraw from all of Sinai."
  • "Arik Sharon, Bibi Netanyahu, Ehud Barak and Rabin, his memory be blessed …each one of them took a step that led us in the right direction, but at some point in time, at some crossroads, when a decision was needed, the decision did not come."
  • "A few days ago I sat in a discussion with the key people in the decision-making process. At the end [I told them]: listening to you, I understand why we have not made peace with the Palestinians and the Syrians during the last 40 years."
  • "We can perhaps take a historic step in our relations with the Palestinians, and a historic step in our relations with the Syrians. In both cases the decision we must make is the decision we have refused to face with open eyes for 40 years."
  • "When you sit on this chair you must ask yourself: where do you direct the effort? To make peace or just to be stronger and stronger and stronger in order to win the war … Our power is great enough to face any danger. Now we must try and see how to use this infrastructure of power in order to make peace and not to win wars."
  • "Iran is a very great power … The assumption that America and Russia and China and Britain and Germany do not know how to handle the Iranians, and we Israelis know and we shall do so, is an example of the loss of all sense of proportion."
  • "I read the statements of our ex-generals and I say: how can it be that they have learned nothing and forgotten nothing?"

The significance of this change of heart is heart to underestimate, and the consequences have yet to fully percolate throuh the Israeli (or American) political system. It's harder to portray these views as 'soft on Israel' coming as they do from a prince of the Israeli right wing, former mayor of Jerusalem, and now, former prime minister.

Comments

  1. Beate Zilversmidt

    Olmert had probably opportunist reasons to say these things which the peace movement has been saying all the time. He needed a smokescreen to hide the very humiliating end of his prime ministership and he hardly could have created a similar effect by suddenly leaning to the right. Still, in spite of the depressing context, he has left us now with something to quote, and - he said these things as acting prime minister, making it hard on his successor to ignore this altogether.

    Posted by Beate Zilversmidt on 10/18/2008 @ 05:04AM PST

    • Report close

      You must be signed in to report content.
  2. Haya K

    I think that Israel is running out of time, the demographic clock is ticking for Israel, Arabs in Israel are growing in numbers and percentage, and yes, they can vote, and no, they are not happy being second class citizens in the Jewish State, on the other hand, the numbers of Palestinians are growing sooo fast, if Israel didn't find a solution that addresses all the major issues that need to be addressed, including: withdrawing from all the lands that were occupied in 1967 including East Jerusalem, and the right of return, or at least a generous compensation for the 1948refugees, if this problem wasn't solved to the satisfaction of all parties within the next few years, the demographic will later impose a diffirent playground where the Palestinians may possibly have an edge, all that Israel need to do now is to withdraw to the pre 1967 boarders, this means that the Palestinians get only 23% of historic Palestine. what is Israel doing in teh West Bank anyway? are they protecting the few religious nuts who are living in the settlements and costing Israel blood, money and international reputation?
    In my opinion, it is in Israel's best interest to just hurry up, and follow the UN resolutions, before the Arabs and the Palestinians start to get the demographic advantage, and then they might not even agree to take back just 23% of historic Palestine.
    Thanks for reading.

    Posted by Haya K on 12/09/2008 @ 12:28AM PST

    • Report close

      You must be signed in to report content.
  3. Eli Williamson-Jones



    I'm promoting an idea for creating lasting peace in the Middle East and the world. It still needs a lot of votes to make it into the second round. Please help provide a more hopeful vision and alternative to the endless spiral of violence escalating in the Middle East by casting your vote today.  Thank you. 
    http://www.change.org/ideas/view/israel_as_cornerstone_for_a_future_united_states_of_earth

    Posted by Eli Williamson-... on 12/29/2008 @ 08:59AM PST

    • Report close

      You must be signed in to report content.
  4. Eli Williamson-Jones

    Earthpledge.net is promoting an idea to create lasting peace in the Middle East and the world. The first proposal wasn't as clear as it needed to be which caused some confusion. Please take a closer look at this hopeful vision and alternative to the endless spiral of violence escalating in the Middle East and cast your vote today. Thank you. 
    http://www.change.org/ideas/view/israel_as_cornerstone_for_a_future_united_states_of_earth
    Also, please check out my friend Josep's proposal for human unity:
    http://www.change.org/ideas/view/human_union

    Posted by Eli Williamson-... on 12/30/2008 @ 08:19AM PST

    • Report close

      You must be signed in to report content.

  5. Firstly- In light of all of the criminal claims against Olmert, I doubt if anyone takes anything he says seriously anymore - He indeed seems like nothing but an oportunist.

    Secondly - Basically, I think peace is more important than land, but have you ever heard the expression - "Give him a finger and he'll want the whole hand?"...History has proven that Arab mentality and wishes are to kick the Israelis completely out of the region. Why would they settle for just a pieace of this area or just a piece of that area?!

    Posted by M Green on 01/01/2009 @ 01:25PM PST

    • Report close

      You must be signed in to report content.

  6. Firstly- In light of all of the criminal claims against Olmert, I doubt if anyone takes anything he says seriously anymore - He indeed seems like nothing but an opportunist.

    Secondly - Basically, I think peace is more important than land, but have you ever heard the expression - "Give him a finger and he'll want the whole hand?"...History has proven that Arab mentality and wishes are to kick the Israelis completely out of the region. Why would they settle for just a pieace of this area or just a piece of that area?!

    Posted by M Green on 01/01/2009 @ 01:25PM PST

    • Report close

      You must be signed in to report content.

  7. Firstly- In light of all of the criminal claims against Olmert, I doubt if anyone takes anything he says seriously anymore - He indeed seems like nothing but an opportunist.

    Secondly - Basically, I think peace is more important than land, but have you ever heard the expression - "Give him a finger and he'll want the whole hand?"...History has proven that Arab mentality and wishes are to kick the Israelis completely out of the region. Why would they settle for just a pieace of this area or just a piece of that area?!

    Posted by M Green on 01/01/2009 @ 01:25PM PST

    • Report close

      You must be signed in to report content.

Add a Comment

For your comment to be published, you will need to confirm your email address after submitting your comment. In the process we will also create a Change.org account for you so you can track this and future conversations. Don't worry - we won't spam you. We just want to promote constructive dialogue and find that people are more respectful when they are not anonymous.

If you already have an account, click here to log in.

Check Spelling

Comments on Change.org are meant for further exploration and evaluation of the ideas covered in the posts. To that end, we welcome constructive comments. However, we reserve the right to delete comments that are offensive, abusive, or off-topic; that contain ad hominem attacks; or that are designed to subvert or hijack comment threads rather than contribute to them. Repeat offenders may be permanently removed from the site at our discretion.

Author

Subscribe to RSS Feed

Charles Lenchner Charles Lenchner
Brooklyn, NY

Charles is a nonprofit professional with 20 years of experience working with nonprofit organizations in Israel, Palestine and the U.S. For the past few years, he's been specializing in online organizing.

Related Blog Posts

close

This user's Profile page is not public. They have restricted it to only their friends.

Already a Member?

Create an Account

You must create a Change.org account to complete this action.
If you already have an account click here.